This blog won’t become a democracy but I’m always interested in feedback. The only problem is that it’s impossible to keep track of feedback when it’s all buried in random articles’ comment sections. I read most comments, but all of them go in one eye and out the other because my memory sucks.
I figured that it would be easier to keep track of any requests, questions, suggestions, complaints, etc. if they were all corralled in one place: This article’s comment section.
So, I’ll be using this article as a pinned post (if I can figure out how to pin it) for a few months to see how this idea plays out. If nobody uses it then I guess I’ll just delete it or whatever but I thought it was worth trying out.
OK TY
EDIT: A note on comment “censorship”
WordPress has an autofilter that requires me to approve certain comments, which is pretty effective at filtering out the idiots. Fortunately, their comments don’t make it out of the gate and are never seen by readers.
Sometimes these idiots cry about “censorship.” So, to be clear, I generally do not approve comments that contain:
- Racial slurs (if the comment is otherwise useful I will edit the slurs out)
- Low IQ sperging
- General schizo behavior
- Essays/textwalls (I don’t have time to read your thesis, sorry)
- URL spam to weird websites
- Fringe nonsense (“Ancient Egyptians were Black”, “Ashkenazis are Turkic”, “The Ainu are Huns”, “The Israelites were White”)
- Libtard nonsense
- Rudeness / aggressiveness for no reason
- etc.
I do not censor comments for:
- Disagreeing with me
Also, sometimes I just forget to approve comments, so good replies accidentally get censored by the auto-filter.
Basically, just don’t be a freak, a doofus, or rude and your comment will be approved. “Be normal” is a perfectly reasonable standard of behavior and the vast majority of people who leave comments do so respectfully but, frankly, some of you people deserve to be censored.
Thuletide 
Hi! How can we have a white ethnostate if no one can agree on who is white and who is not. Whenever the question of the whiteness of a people arises, there is always a dispute.
I mean, without exaggeration, people literally arguing about whether Italians, Irish, Slavs, Finns, South Americans, Jews, Syrians, Caucasians, Iranians, Turks, Japanese are white or not, seems hopeless.
What do you think about switching from the term “White” to something clearer like “Native European” or similar?
LikeLike
I answered “who is White?” here: https://t.me/thuletide/4782
It’s very simple to define and people are only confused because there is so much stupid disinformation and bad rhetoric on the subject.
LikeLike
This is a good classification and I agree with it.
But what I’m afraid of is that there is no general agreement, and it’s hard to believe that there will be one soon. The White movement should be based on something clearly defined, well-known and agreed upon. I am almost sure that there will be problems with the whole “who is White” thing in the future.
Or maybe I’m just blackpilled by ignorant NPCs on social media…
LikeLike
Here you can see that whites are divided into two large groups – northern Europeans and southern Europeans. The Greeks and Portuguese are a threat to the existence of the few small-bearing Scottish redheads and Estonian blue-eyed beauties, as well as non-Europeans. At least most of them. I don’t want these traits to disappear.
Naturally, if the right comes to power in some Italy, I will be happy for them, and if I fail to find a good northern girl, I will not refuse a girl with a southern European phenotype in love with me, but still, even if we forget about the problem with migrants , I don’t really like the lack of an actual border between European countries: people from southern Europe, especially the Balkans, will inevitably go to the North, at least for economic reasons. I’m interested in what you think about this problem.
LikeLike
I don’t think South Europeans are a threat. They would be insane to move from their conservative countries to degenerate North/West. But yeah, gotta keep the South Europeans in South Europe to preserve Northern phenotype, culture, genetics.
LikeLike
“I don’t think South Europeans are a threat. They would be insane to move from their conservative countries to degenerate North/West.”
Southern Europe is actually not far behind the degenerate North/West. Eastern Europe is most conservative.
LikeLike
Yes words like white and black should be abandoned, or instead be used as transracial descriptors (like “brown”, which covers MENAs, Hispanics, South Asians etc)
One of the biggest driving favors behind race denialism is people thinking race is “just skin color”
LikeLike
That’s dumb, everyone knows White means European and Black means Sub-Saharan African.
LikeLike
No, many people take it too literally and think it means “very pale-skinned”. Hasan Piker is considered white by just about everyone, despite being very open about his Turkish background.
There’s also a lot of confusion, the US Census categorizes (or used to at least) brown-skinned Latin Americans and Central Asians as white.
LikeLike
“Low impulse control isn’t just criminality, it’s the inability to prevent yourself from engaging in behaviors that are harmful to yourself or your community. In this case, running around shouting Nazi stuff and being a punching bag for the Left while discrediting the Right.”
It also makes the left look bad for defending pedophiles, which is what they are obviously doing. They call anyone who is pro-white a “Nazi”, it acts as a slur originating from the Marxist jew Konrad Heiden in Germany who coined the term as an inversion of “Sozi” to imply the NSDAP consisted of backward hillbillies.
What is bad about actual “Nazi” stuff as opposed to the larpers? The German National Socialists in the 30s and 40s were nothing like how they are portrayed in jewish media.
Most of the skinheads are gone and they only existed as a result of men like William Pierce trying to draw in the youth with the heavy metal genre of music.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Left has been defending pedophiles for decades and having a bunch of Neo-Nazis shouting at them isn’t going to make them look any worse, it just makes the Right look bad.
LikeLike
The ideology of National Socialism is nevertheless solid and logically sound. Your own views aren’t far off from its philosophy, despite the many lies and slanders that misrepresent NS. This by extension attracts the very sort of antisocial people it actually opposed.
The term “Nazi/Nazism” is a political epithet coined by the Marxist jew Konrad Heiden to denigrate Hitler and National Socialism. Heiden was a propagandist and member of the SPD (Social Democrat Party).
The term “Nazi” is a variation of the nickname that was used in reference to members of Heiden’s SDP at the time.
“Sozi” (short for Sozialisten). Nazi was a political pun, based upon the Austro-Bavarian slang word for “simpleton” or “country bumpkind” and derived from the fairly common name ‘Ignatz’, it would be like saying “nutsy”.
So, if for no other reason, one should easily understand why the term was regarded as derogatory by t he National Socialists and why they very rarely used it to describe themselves.
LikeLiked by 1 person
More on that (roughly 5:22 – 15:30) – Mentions you around 13:00 https://odysee.com/@Thomas_Sewell:e/31:3f
LikeLike
I only listened briefly but he basically said some guy said all of the stuff that he is saying but without the Nazi stuff and everyone agreed with him. Then he says “but that doesn’t matter because agreement is not support” and goes on to say that he wants to build infrastructure IRL.
Okay fair point, but are people going to be more or less likely to support someone who openly preaches Nazi stuff? Are people going to get involved with that IRL? No, obviously not, it’s just more unnecessary risk. It’s like voluntarily going into a boxing match with one or even both hands tied behind your back.
I saw a brief interview with Sewell that was on Australian TV. He was very articulate, shut down all Leftist arguments thrown at him, didn’t mention any Nazi stuff. People will see this and think “hey this guy is talking sense,” then go to check him out and see a bunch of Hitler stuff and immediately bail out.
LikeLike
They call everyone they don’t like a “nazi”. Unless someone knows what they are, you might as well name the Bellamy salute and the fact Boy Scouts and many others used to hoist the Swastika. Apparently, “optics” matter , despite the Senate maintaining the symbol.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces#Examples_of_US_fasces_iconography
LikeLike
He said even if they don’t like his “Nazi stuff” they may agree with him but won’t support him anyway. Since those are two different things.
He says if someone would rather reject him over his Nazi stuff than band together to deal with the problem, they are apart of the problem. Even Enoch Powell who fought Rommel in Africa urged all Whites, whether Conservatives or “Fascists/Nazis” should band together to keep Britain White.
Anyone who wants White racialism and traditional values is castigated as a “Nazi” anyway. Even by alleged “Conservatives”, most of whom are indeed Liberals.
Without the excesses of [Classical] Liberalism, this would never have been a problem to begin with.
They will only start getting it when Whites are a minority in every country, then they will think to themselves:
“Yes, things were much, much better when our nations were almost completely White”.
We need a level of racialist tribalism on the level of pagan Europe in Antiquity, comparable to what was found among the “barbarian” peoples.
LikeLike
“if someone would rather reject him over his Nazi stuff than band together to deal with the problem, they are apart of the problem.”
That’s just dumb idealism from somebody who lives in a LARPy fantasy world. Politics is the art of the possible. Drop the Nazi stuff if you want to make a real-world impact. It’s pretty simple.
LikeLike
The cameras will often shut off when he doesn’t do “Nazi stuff”. George Lincoln Rockwell talked about that sort of thing.
LikeLike
Do you get all of your ancient and modern genetic samples from the Eurogenes blog?
LikeLike
No, from the Vahaduo website.
LikeLike
I remember in one of your articles there were detailed statistics, the percentage of Jews in the US Army, the percentage of Jews in the US Parliament … And so on. So, I can’t find it in any way, can you help me and remind me in which article it was, or just throw off a link to the sources where the information was taken from, thanks in advance
LikeLike
IIRC, it’s in my original Ashkenazi Jewish IQ article.
LikeLike
Have you ever researched or come across other people’s research on the jewish admixture of European Royalty/American Presidents?
There is a schizo conspiracy theorist named Miles Mathis, I’m sure you’ve heard of him, who claims (through his own “research”) that essentially every single influential White Person; Royals, Inventors, Philosophers, etc., have been “jewish”. Crypto jews to be precise. Even the Vikings!
I don’t doubt that there have been many cryptos throughout our collective history, but to the extent this guy makes it out to be seems rather ludicrous. I think he’s a demoralization agent. I notice quite a number of people in the these spheres repeat some of his conspiracies. Kind of connects to the whole “Anglos are jews” which is popular at the moment.
“Yeah goy, all of your race’s hero’s and Greats were really JEWS! You’ve always been ruled by jews, so why even try to fight us!”
Anyway, I was really just curious to the extent that jews married into European bloodlines, and if this plays a role in our Elites hating us so much.
LikeLike
I haven’t looked into admixture between Jews and elite Europeans before, but Mathis believes a lot of kooky things and is not a guy who should be taken seriously. You could take a look at the ancestries of a handful of elite Jewish families and see how often they married non-Jews.
I just looked at Rothschilds, Oppenheims, Warburgs and noticed that they didn’t marry non-Jews until the 20th Century and even then it was rare. It seems that they just married into other prominent Jewish families, probably to keep wealth within their ethnic group. Bankers’ daughters marrying rabbis was very common.
The average Ashkenazi is around 50% Middle Eastern, 30% South European, and 20% North European. That’s after ~2000 years of living in Europe and the South European admixture date is very early in the first millennium. They wouldn’t exist as a population anymore if they had been intermixing with Europeans the whole time.
LikeLike
You’re right that they wouldn’t exist as a population anymore if they had been mixing with Europeans the whole time. But I guess the conspiracy revolves around “bloodlines” that married into the European Elite at an early time, in order to infiltrate/Conquer in the usual jewish fashion, not necessarily the entire population of jews. I’m not sure, some of the Elites have been quite nice to the jews over the centuries. And it’s hard for me to think people like Charlemagne were genuinely European given that he banned usury for Gentiles and allowed jews to create a monopoly on the practice. Even though it was the Catholic Church’s influence that led to that. I’m also very skeptical of the Catholic Church, and its history/behavior toward Northern Europeans. The conversion of Germanic peoples to Christianity seems to be Rome’s long-awaited “success” in finally conquering those “pesky barbarians”.
LikeLike
Is it true that there’s no such thing as a “French” ethnicity? I occasionally see this claim on Reddit. Here are some comments:
>Ethnic french does not exist anymore. We are a crossroad in Europe with too many borders to have one type of population.
>Ethnic french has never existed period. We have Celtic, Gallo-Roman, Occitan, Germanic etc etc people all gathered around a kingdom and then the ideal of a Révolution. Martinique and Guadeloupe were French before Lille or Nice. It just doesn’t make sense to treat it as anything different than a bunch of different people sharing an idea of what a country should be
Context is the French soccer team having too many non-white and non-French players so might just be leftists talking out of their ass, but I’ve seen it on ancestry subreddits as well.
LikeLike
No of course there is a French ethnicity. An ethnic group is people who descend from the same ancestral populations, speak the same language, share the same culture, and usually same religion.
French people have mixed ancestry from Celts and Germanics and some Med ancestry from the Roman empire. These proportions of ancestry exist on a gradient throughout the country, which is the 3rd biggest country in Europe behind Ukraine and Russia.
It’s the typical “English people don’t exist because you have ancestry from Celts, Anglo-Saxons, and Vikings :^)” argument.
LikeLike
Do you consider Finns mixed-race? According to wiki they are up to 10% Siberian.
LikeLike
Nah Finns are White. Some have slight East Asian features but they’re not like Saami or Tatars or anything. Well, even Saami and Tatars with more East Asian features still look pretty White.
LikeLike
How to raise the European birth rate? It’s clear what can be done once you’ve gained political power, abolish no-fault divorces, ban hormonal contraception, and so on. But what can we do as long as we have no political power?
Is it possible to create a community with alternative values, in which children will not be a rarity and which will encourage intra-group cooperation? Is it possible to create such a society without Christianity? And no religion at all? If yes, how to achieve this?
LikeLike
Impossible to raise it without political power but communities like the Amish and Mormons have very high birth rates. They’re very religious and religiosity in general correlates with fertility. Unfortunately, Christianity preaches racial universalism so it is cursed with a huge backdoor to immigration and multiracialism. I would be amazed if the Amish and Mormon communities remain homogeneously White over the coming decades.
LikeLike
Is it possible to create something similar to the Amish, in our era? I think that the Amish will remain more white anyway, even with the declared universalism, since joining the ranks of the Amish is too expensive, especially for a modern “urban” person. What really threatens the Amish is a variety of climate change programs, public school enforcement, and other forms of direct government violence. Mormons will have problems (if they haven’t already) because Mormonism is too open and much less demanding.
Why did Asatru and any other neo-pagans (as far as I know) fail in this matter completely? Can any pagan group be expected to come along and solve this for the members of that group? If someone tried to create such a group, what would you advise?
LikeLike
Have you ever thought about writing an article or a thread on Thomas Sowell’s theories, or rather assertions that White Southerners are responsible for “black ghetto culture”? He seems to justify this for several reasons; White Northerners viewed White Southerners as “uncivilized”, crime ridden, having a poor work-ethic, as well as being unusually “violent”. He appears to presume that this alleged “culture” of White Southerners was “transplanted” onto negroes. I find this ridiculous.
In addition to this obnoxiously stupid and Anti-White narrative he pushes, he also completely disregards a genetic explanation for black behavior, such as IQ and other innate factors. I’ve even seen him laughably claim that Victorian Era Whites were as smart as present day blacks in America! Obviously he uses The Flynn Effect to suggest this, and, without any evidence, assumes that blacks are actually “becoming smarter”… “They’ll be like White People in future”, is what he believes. He also uses several German Studies concerning mulattos born and raised by German woman who were “just as smart” as their full-blooded German counter-parts, or something stupid like that. “So it must be culture and environment!”, is his argument.
I don’t know too much about Sowell, but checking out his Wikipedia page it states that some of his influences were Marx and Milton Friedman, who Sowell was a student of.
I guess I appreciate some of the stuff he’s said about the true nature of the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade, but I think he’s idiotic for the things I mentioned above. And I’m sick of seeing “right-wing” people repeat his nonsense. I’m tired of so-called “based” non-Whites in general.
LikeLike
I don’t ever see anyone talking about that guy, so probably not.
LikeLike
You’ve talked about how Atatürk and Dönmeh Jews played a role in the current world order before, could you explain more on why and how? How did the dismantling of the Ottoman Empire help them? Apparently Atatürk being a Dönmeh himself was also a frequent and common rumor.
LikeLike
I don’t think I’ve ever said they helped build the NWO, just pointed out that they were an example of Sabbateanism being linked to Left-Wing revolutions.
LikeLike
Hey Thule,
At one point you posted an unlisted youtube video by STJ talking about a study on Greek ancestry, and I can’t find it on your blog anymore. Do you have a link? I would look it up, but it was unlisted.
LikeLike
I don’t remember it but it was probably a summary of this study: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867421003706
LikeLike
You wrote a lot about Eurasianist/Duginist subversion on the Right, but I think the war in Ukraine is also pushing many nationalists to the other extreme (NATO/EU shilling), do you agree?
LikeLike
It appears that White Americans, while comparable to Europeans, do in fact have higher homicide rates than Native Europeans.
Do you have any theories for why this is? Could it be Genetic?
The “go to” answer is “muh guns”, which I disagree with, but even if it was true; taking our guns away because blacks can’t stop shooting each other is a humorous cope for leftists. It’s incontestable to anyone with a brain that White Americans are not responsible for America’s gun violence/homicide rate.
On the other hand, I am quite amazed at how low the Homicide Rate is in many European Nations, even after substantial nonWhite, third-world immigration. Of course, this is not factoring in general crime such as assault, rape, etc., which has surely skyrocketed since the flooding of turd-skins in Europe. I am strictly talking about homicide, in which America has around 5 murders per 100k.
I’d love to see a study breaking down White Crime by ethnicity in America. I wonder if we’d see certain groups being more criminally inclined.
LikeLike
Source? All data have seen shows that White Americans have homicide rates that align with Northwestern Europe.
LikeLike
I just looked at the data in your article on international crime rates.
This one in particular showed Homicide rates from 1999-2015. In 2015, the Homicide rate for Non-Hispanic White Americans was 2.6. Isn’t this slightly higher than most NW European Nations?
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/66/wr/mm6631a9.htm
Tbh, I might be wrong. If I am, I apologize.
LikeLike
I am curious, do you think white South Africans should be deported back to Europe?
LikeLike
No they should conquer the South African peninsula and use it as a base of operations for Whites on the African continent.
LikeLike
What do you think of Singapore executing drug traffickers? Recently someone was hanged for trafficking cannabis
LikeLike
Drug trafficking should be capitally punished.
LikeLike
What do you think about the complexes of Eastern Europeans?
“Western Europe never recognized us as their own, we were barbaric strangers to the French, Slavic slaves were sold in Prague and Venice, Orthodoxy/Ottomans/Mongols/Communism tore us from the West, and now Polish workers flock to Britain, Ukrainian prostitutes to The Netherlands, and any Slavs with brains leave in horror, because our countries have no chance, and we will remain second-rate Europeans.”
LikeLike
I don’t know how common that view is in Eastern Europe but it’s very cucked. Many Eastern European countries are in a healthier state than the West, they should have more pride in their history. Defeating the Mongols and Ottomans and overthrowing Communism in all countries (except Russia which is currently basically just Communism-Lite with an Orthodox veneer) are all very admirable feats.
LikeLike
I heard from Edward Dutton that even Finland has this problem. Britain and Finland have a comparable level of economic success (judging by some parameters, Finland is richer and more prosperous than Britain), Finland single-handedly fought off the Goliath of the Soviet Union, but the data shows that Finnish women are incomparably becoming the wives of the British than British women are the wives of the Finns, but indicating a difference in status between the groups.
If even Finland has such a problem, what can we say about much less successful countries?
LikeLike
Do you believe that eventually, vaccines (not the MRNA jab, but the ”traditional” vaccination plans in Western countries) will be thrown into the dustbin of history and more parents will choose natural immunity? Or that in the future, there would be different methods available for the human body to practice against diverse pathogens, without the heavy metals etc. that shouldn’t belong in the human body? Ofc every parent wants the best for their child.
LikeLike
I think many will be looked upon as snake oil quack medicines in the future. I’ve always been skeptical of vaccines due to their heavy metal content and so on. After seeing data showing that all diseases were declined to very low levels long before any vaccine was invented for them, I trusted them even less.
LikeLike
What is your opinion on the Protestant Reformation? Did it lead to the current problems we face today? I’ll admit; I get somewhat annoyed by Catholic Americans complaining about our Protestant roots. Ultimately, they are not and should have never been part of this country. The entrance of Catholics and jews coincidentally coincides with America’s aggressive push to leftism. Catholics are more accepting of left-wing social values than Protestants are too.
LikeLike
On the one hand, the Reformation did strangle the Renaissance, which was a revival of pagan ideals from Classical Antiquity. But on the other hand, it separated Northern Europeans from foreign influence.
Catholics are indeed far more Left-Wing than Protestants in America and they are significantly responsible for America’s decline because they provided the much-needed voter base to actually get Left-Wing people in power. If America had no Catholic immigration, it would probably still be Right-Wing, 90% White, have no Civil Rights laws, etc.
People don’t like to talk about the Catholic Question and many even have this delusional idea that Catholicism is somehow a bulwark against Globalism and Leftism when, in reality, it is a source of both.
LikeLike
1. Was the founder of the Bavarian Illuminati (Adam Weishaupt) a Crypto-Jew?
2. Is the religion of Luciferianism a type Theistic Satanism (devil worship) or is it based on gnosticism and the Kabbalah?
3. Is the rothschild family really worth 500 trillion dollars and owns allegedly half of the world’s wealth?
LikeLike
Yes, not sure, probably not.
LikeLike
Thuletide, do you think that the elites comprises of only unironic libtards who believe what they believe in or only sociopath, psychopath, narcissist, self-centered people? Or mix of both? If mix of both, which do you think has the bigger number?
LikeLike
Mix of both. Many I presume are just indoctrinated by Leftist poison in elite academia, but some will be of the psychopathic Leftist type. Difficult to put a figure on it because they all promote the same stuff.
LikeLike
I wonder why you sometimes post screen caps of Musk saying “based” things on Twitter in your Telegram channel…yeah they’re true, but he calls out this stuff only in the end when it’s safe to do so. It really doesn’t matter anymore then (see vaccines, promoting it previously everywhere and is involved in every trans-humanist endeavor imaginable). Additionally, he often only tackles pretty normie stuff to stir up controversy and portray himself as “free-speech” or dissident, even though he’s plainly just controlled opposition and on board with everything of the globalist agenda. He’s one of the world’s richest and most influential people after all, it’s really incredible how people still fall for his scams.
LikeLike
Hey Thule, saw a question on Twitter that I’d like to see your answer to:
“Jokes aside, somebody explain why there are so many non-white guys who are unironic white supremacists?”
LikeLike
Well, Whites are objectively the best so maybe some of them are just honest. But I imagine that many of them are mentally disturbed. Such people are basically the non-White equivalent of White Leftists. Zero in-group preference and betraying their kinsmen. Totally untrustworthy.
LikeLike
Do you think Eva Vlaardingerbroek, daughter of Kees Vlaardingerbroek (now deceased) is Eurotrash? She is now married to Will Witt, spokesman for Prager U (Dennis Prager). She met Dennis Prager, a Zionist and socialite jew. Spoke with Kabbalah bracelet Tucker Carleson, and romantically involved with Julien Rochedy and Thierry Baudet.
LikeLike
Can you explain to me the significance of blacks tracing 19% of their ancestry to Homo erectus?
IIRC the entire human species descends from Homo erectus.
LikeLike
They don’t have ancestry from Homo erectus, just an unknown archaic ghost population that split from other humans before Neanderthals and Denisovans did. They have 2-19% ancestry from this population so it definitely impacted their phenotype to some degree.
LikeLike
In what ways do you think the ghost population admixture impacted the phenotype of subsaharan Africans?
LikeLike
How much different would the Indo-Europeans have looked from the Early European Farmers that they mostly conquered/genocided while taking the woman? I always assumed, since light features were present yet not as common as today, that it would have been two like skin populations, mostly brown hair/eyes, yet with the Steppe Warriors being much taller than the Farmers. So basically two White populations, with one conquering the other and establishing the genetic basis for modern Europeans. One scientist I read said that the Indo-Europeans were our “main ancestor”; I agree with that statement. We are them, more or less.
There seems to be so much disinformation/subversion around this topic. Most of the facial reconstructions I see make the IE look brown. The only time I see reasonable reconstructions is from independent artists. You also have South Asians and other brown people who claim that the Corded Ware/Yamnaya were swarthy middle eastern men conquering light skin farmers and taking their woman. I’m sure they do this just to piss off White People interested in the history of their ancestors. And the media seems to engage in the same behavior as basically every ancient European in shown as dark skin/not European looking at all. As if White People have only existed for 2000 years or something preposterous.
LikeLike
Early European Farmers were shorter and more gracile, Proto-Indo-Europeans were more taller and more robust. But even after mixing with EEF women PIE were still more robust than modern Europeans.
In terms of pigmentation, the difference was probably minimal. Neither population had high frequencies of blond hair, EEF at this point maybe had slightly higher frequencies of blue eyes due to having 25% WHG ancestry, and both probably had intermediate skin similar to modern Sardinians with some fairer people among them.
Modern Northwest Europeans are basically genetically identical to Early Bronze Age Indo-Europeans of north/western Europe but iirc we have more blondism than they did, and we are not as robust due to environmental factors (cucked diet etc.):
LikeLike
Any thoughts on the Cleopatra netflix documentary?
LikeLike
I’m glad that they’re producing such blatant anti-White historical revisionism. It makes our job of pointing out the anti-White agenda a lot easier and also makes everyone hate the media.
LikeLike
Do you plan on making a small post about arch-globalist Henry Kissinger since his 100th birthday is on Saturday the 27th? Him heading the 9/11 commission and refusing to disclose from where he got his funding.
That vampire probably doesn’t lose sleep over handing half of SE Asia a death sentence (Paris Peace Accords).
[Kissinger on initiating the rise of Red China. Backing the Red Chinese over the Soviets. Anatoliy Golitsyn warned that the West would be lured into lowering its defenses (Perestroika Deception) believing they won the Cold War.]
>…we back the weaker against the stronger. It’s no great insight for Britishers but in America that is not the way foreign policy is usually perceived. And then we started from then on we started moving actively and took measures to find means of contact with the Chinese.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/china-kissinger-interview/
LikeLike
Hi, i’m wondering about Kabyles. Is it “race-mixing” for a european to unite with a Kabyles/half-Kabyles ?
I mean, i would not be happy to find out i have Kabyles ancestry, so i don’t wish that for my child. Or am i exaggerating things ?
Thanks
LikeLike
North Africans are a separate race to Europeans, so yes.
LikeLike
To keep his chin up could we say that’s still White even if not European, and that this kind of race-mixing won’t really matter ?
LikeLike
They’re not White because White means European and it will matter because North Africans have 85 average IQ. If you are talking about your friend then you can decide if it’s more kind to lie or tell the truth. At least with a European-looking Kabyle the kids won’t look much different from Whites.
LikeLike
Not to promote race-mixing, but MENAs appear to have an IQ of 96 in the US:
Seems they are not nearly as dysfunctional and violent as in Europe. Though that may be in part due to the far smaller population size
LikeLike
Maybe because Jews are grouped in with other MENAs here, or maybe because the immigrants who move to America are wealthier and therefore smarter.
LikeLike
Maybe he will chin up if u tell him that North Africans and Europeans belong to the same subspecies, they are both Caucasoid / West Eurasian
LikeLike
Ok, thank you. Not the worst race mixing when they look like White and are already race-mixed with european, but still race mixing. That’s sad for them when they feel and look like european. Race mixing isn’t good for children 😔
Btw, about Zemmour, i saw an old article of you. He indeed said good things and shift the overton window. For that, he was useful. But he is still an opponent to our cause. Lately shaming the RN for antisemitism is a good example of his true face.
LikeLike
I don’t think North Africans feel European at all. Usually they are very proud of being Berbers. And their European ancestry is from the Neolithic + White slave trade.
Regarding Zemmour, of course, he is Jewish so he will always advocate for his people’s interests not matter how useful he is for shifting the Overton window.
LikeLike
When discussing socialism, is there any reason to differentiate between soviet statism (state run factories), and “democratizing the workplace” style socialism like in the Scandinavian states? Do worker co-ops actually achieve any leftwing goals, or are they meaningless in the long run? Do worker co-ops typically operate under heavy control of the government? Why have leftists made this shift in their concept of what socialism is?
LikeLike
They shifted because the USSR was bad optics so they claimed to be “democratic socialists” instead of Communists but they believe all of the same stuff. There is basically no point in distinguishing between different forms of socialism.
LikeLike
Opinion on Josh Neal and his book? Do you think he is detrimental to Us due to his friendship with Joel Davis?
LikeLike
No idea who that is but I like Joel Davis. We’ve argued before and called each other retards but it wasn’t personal.
LikeLike
Will two siblings from the same biological parents have same amounts of admixture from their shared ancestral groups if they both take a dna test?
LikeLike
It can vary slightly because genetic recombination is a random process but generally the amount will be very similar in non-recently admixed populations that have homogenized.
LikeLike
Is an anti-woke backlash happening in your opinion?
LikeLike
Among the masses? It began like 8 years ago and the Overton window is constantly shifting right.
LikeLike
I have a couple questions.
Do Russians have East Asian admixture?
What modern day populations are the closest to Ancient North Eurasians?
LikeLike
People in North and East of Russia have East Asian admixture, averaging about 5%, but a lot of them are Russian-speaking people of Finno-Ugric origin. Russians in the West, who are of Slavic origin, do not have East Asian ancestry.
The closest modern populations to ANE are Uralic-type peoples with 80% West Eurasian ancestry and 20% East Eurasian ancestry: Udmurts, Besermyans, Chuvash, Mari, Komi, Saami. But these peoples are more closely related to West Siberian Hunter-Gatherers, who had slightly more East Eurasian ancestry than the ANE.
For an idea of what ANE looked like, see the images in this post: https://thuletide.wordpress.com/2022/06/12/faces-of-the-ancient-north-eurasians/
LikeLike
Is it true that Hadrian and atinous were gay?
LikeLike
Never looked into it. Sounds suspicious to me.
LikeLike
Where do you respond the quickest? Here, Twitter DMs, or Gab DMs?
LikeLike
Twitter probably
LikeLike
Is it better to use average or individual samples to create the most accurate vahaduo models?
LikeLike
Depends what information you’re looking for. Generally averaged samples for source populations.
LikeLike
hey brah, can we still get access to that European Aesthetics Mega folder of yours, I lost the link but I need those pictures to sustain my soul. TY
LikeLike
Unfortunately not, Mega killed it I think.
LikeLike
How European were Sogdians, Wusun, Bactrians, and Yuezhi? I ask these specifically because I can’t even find a g25 for them.
LikeLike
Sogdian (Kangju) and Wusun samples are on G25: https://i.ibb.co/ZKndMzD/Sogdians-Wusun.jpg
Andronovo were genetically near-identical to modern Northern Europeans, but Sogdians and Wusun had 12% East Asian and 20% BMAC ancestry on average. So they would probably look White but genetically they were not White as we understand it today. They were are most genetically similar to modern Pamiris (their direct descendants), many of whom still look White today, even though they have (iirc) 20-30% less Andronovo ancestry than Sogdians and Wusun: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pamiris
LikeLike
Thanks. Are bactrians just bmac then or do they have Andronovo admixture?
LikeLike
Bactrians I presume were similar to Sogdians since they lived right next to each other. Maybe Bactrians had more Middle Eastern and South Asian admixture because they lived closer to Iran and India. No samples available yet. Post here with some more info: https://t.me/thuletide/5257
LikeLike
Does Ethiopian mota also have ghost species dna or it’s really a western African thing?
LikeLike
Unsure
LikeLike
Were Maltese people legally allowed to naturalize in early America?
LikeLike
No idea.
LikeLike
Substack coming soon? Would you ever do a youtube channel? Do you think you will keep being an online personality, or will you grow out of this eventually?
LikeLike
How to debunk:
“Whites will never go extinct because even if a mixed White/X Race exists in the future White genes will still live on.”
This argument basically says exactly that; Whites cannot truly go extinct because our genes will still exist in whatever future mixed race exists. Of course, our phenotype can no longer exist, but these race denialists do not care about that and will use any argument to simultaneously justify our replacement and assure us that we are conspiracy theorists for being concerned with our own self-preservation.
LikeLike
Neanderthals are classified as extinct and they went extinct by interbreeding with Early Modern Humans until they didn’t exist anymore. The same applies to racial and ethnic groups.
LikeLike
Thuletide, do you believe there is any reason to doubt the official holocaust narrative? Specifically the claim that millions of Jews were murdered in gas chambers and mass shootings. I don’t have a better excuse for not doing more of my own research besides a) both sides engage in a lot of obnoxious / distracting / dishonest sperging and b) it’s hard to believe that such a massive event could be convincingly fabricated. I’ve had difficulty finding sources who are pro-white, aware of the JQ, and not infatuated with Hitler or the Third Reich. You seem to fit the bill so I’d like your opinion.
LikeLike
Definitely true:
– Nazi put a lot of Jews in camps.
– Various Nazi leaders said verbatim “We are going to eradicate Jewry in Europe.”
– The original plan was to deport all Jews to Israel but during late WW2 (1942 iirc) they seemed to say “screw it” and just started killing them.
– Some elements (e.g. SS) carried out mass shootings and probably killed a high number of Jews via this method alone.
– A lot of Germans (including NSDAP party members and leadership) were unaware of mass killings.
– The death toll at places like Auschwitz has been officially revised and reduced multiple times.
– Camps were plagued by disease and supply lines were destroyed by allies; many Jews died due to these factors alone (but if you put someone in a prison camp and they die of starvation or disease, then you’re still to blame).
Definitely false:
– Masturbation machines and other things invented by insane people for propaganda purposes.
Difficult to discern:
– Total death toll. 250,000 is too low but 6,000,000 is too high (accounting for official revisions and so on).
Weird but possibly true:
– Mass gassings. Fake showers are inefficient and convoluted, why didn’t they just shoot them? And why are there so many strange narratives surrounding this? Still, it’s definitely more believable than masturbation machines.
When people claim that their relatives were masturbated to death, it does bring the entire narrative into question, but there’s no way it was totally fabricated. I don’t think it really matters if the mass gassings actually happened or not. Nazis didn’t like Jews and put a lot of them in camps where they died from various causes including execution, and a lot of Jews were killed in mass shootings across Eastern Europe.
Frankly, I don’t think there’s any point in debating it. I follow the Sargon approach of “I don’t care about the Holocaust.” It happened almost a century ago and nobody in the Anglosphere had anything to do with it. 60 million Whites died during WW2 and countless millions of civilians were intentionally killed by every side in the conflict, why should one small fraction of the dead get special treatment? We need to step over this, getting bogged down in revisionism is a total waste of time.
LikeLike
Do you have this approach to historical white genocides / persecutions as well?
LikeLike
No that’s stupid, we should hold grudges forever.
LikeLike
Hey I’d like to know your thoughts on this:
Why has anti-white racism and far-leftism become so normalized in the past few years?
I know so many people, once reasonable and normal, that have turned into deranged stereotypical SJWs, one white person I know became extremely self-hating and seems to worship blacks; basically told me it’s ok for blacks to hate whites
It has always existed of course but these creatures used to be stigmatized and made fun of, even by regular people. Anti-SJW content was quite popular back in like 2015-17. Now they seem to be the norm.
LikeLike
Civil Rights laws + increasing Leftist control of academia, media, education system, etc. It’s the hegemonic ideology, enforced basically down the barrel of a gun, so normies just accept that it is reality. Many of these herd animals would be Nazis in mid century Germany. Radical Leftists are a different breed though.
LikeLike
Is G25 a reliable source?
LikeLike
G25 is a very reliable source if the person who is making the models actually knows what they’re doing.
LikeLike
Substack coming soon? Would you ever create a youtube/Odyssey? Also is there any reason you deleted your article on caucus genetics? I really enjoyed that one.
LikeLike
Well I was considering working on more articles and stuff but they just take so long to write and I get bored. Currently thinking about creating a redpill archive website, more info here: https://t.me/thuletide/5142
LikeLike
You been following ufo stuff lately? Discussion seems to be heating up again. Do you buy any of it, or is this some government constructed hoax meant for nefarious purposes?
LikeLike
I think it’s total nonsense promoted to distract people.
LikeLike
G25 samples I saw suggested Ancient Greeks were genetically closer to modern eastern populations than to Scandinavians and Germannics. Is this accurate?
LikeLike
What do you mean by eastern? Eastern Europe?
LikeLike
No he means West Asian, Middle East.
LikeLike